Free Diagnostic
Sector Benchmark Report
HR Consultancy / 2026

How Ten HR Consultancies Present Themselves
and What It's Costing Them

Average combined score: 24.3 out of 60. Not a single firm scored above 35. Three failure patterns appeared in nine of the ten firms studied.

10
Firms assessed
24.3
Avg score /60
0
Scored above 35
Download Free Report

Enter your email and we will send you the full PDF report. No sign-up sequence. No sales call. Just the report.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

Please enter a valid email address.
Report on its way.

Check your inbox. The full PDF report has been sent to the email address you provided. If it does not arrive within a few minutes, check your spam folder.

Take the free diagnostic while you wait →
✓ 26 pages ✓ Individual firm diagnostics ✓ Untaken positions identified ✓ Free to download
What the report covers

Six sections. No filler.

  • 01 Score SummaryAll ten firms scored across the 5S Proposition Score and Commercial Architecture Score. Combined scores out of 60. Verdict tier for each firm.
  • 02 Market-Wide Failure PatternsThe four named failure patterns. How many firms each affects. The commercial consequence for each pattern. Why they keep recurring.
  • 03 Commercial Architecture AnalysisSeven-layer assessment across all ten firms. Average score per layer. The Solid Foundation Rule applied. Where firms are investing in the wrong things.
  • 04 The Buyer Journey NarrativeWhat the benchmark reveals about the actual buying experience for a founder searching for HR support. Why it ends in a decision based on Google reviews and quoted rate.
  • 05 Individual Firm DiagnosticsAll ten firms individually. Failure patterns identified. Core commercial problem. And for each firm: the untaken position the market is currently leaving open.
  • 06 What Good Looks LikeThe four characteristics no firm in this study demonstrates in combination. The untaken position in UK HR consultancy. What the firm that claims it will own.
Sample findings

What the data shows

The Mirror Trap
9/10

Nine of the ten firms opened their homepage with a description of what they do rather than the buyer's problem. The Mirror Trap eliminates the best prospects before they make contact.

The Trophy Cabinet
9/10

Proof exists but creates no belief. Logos, years of experience, client counts. No outcomes narrated. No context. No before and after. Credentials without cases.

Layer 6: Public Proof
1.6/5

The lowest average score across all seven Commercial Architecture layers. Teaching in public is almost entirely absent. Content, where it exists, is compliance updates or service descriptions.

The firm that claims the untaken position does not need to be larger, cheaper, or more experienced than its competitors. It needs to be clearer. In this market, clarity is the scarcest resource.
Addoli Proposition Architect Framework | HR Consultancy Benchmark 2026
Score preview

All ten firms. All scores visible.

The full report includes individual diagnostics for each firm: failure patterns identified, core commercial problem, and the untaken position the market is currently leaving open.

Firm Archetype 5S /25 CA /35 Combined /60 Verdict
AThe Full-Service Generalist81119Fragile
BThe HR Tech Platform141832Functioning
CThe Accountancy Firm Add-On7916Fragile
DThe Volume Compliance Provider152035Functioning
EThe SME People Partner111324Developing
FThe Legal-Backed HR Practice91221Fragile
GThe HR Software Ecosystem101323Developing
HThe Specialist Niche Practice121628Developing
IThe Regional Partnership Practice101424Developing
JThe Commercial HR Generalist91221Fragile
Market Average (all ten firms)10.513.824.3—

Full individual diagnostics, failure patterns, and untaken positions in the report. Free to download above.

See where your
proposition sits.
Free. 5 minutes.

Take the free Proposition Architect diagnostic. Named failure pattern. Combined score out of 60. Priority fix sequence. Instant result.

Take the free diagnostic →